Innovation is King: Only What Truly Advances a Problem Deserves to be Called Innovation
-
摘要:
第5篇《工具之后,问题仍在》已经说明,强工具时代不能把人的判断交给工具;第6篇《问题为本》进一步把研究拉回真实对象、矛盾和边界.本文沿着这个次序再往前问一步:真实问题立住以后,研究怎样才算真正向前?基本判断很清楚:问题管起点,创新管推进.问题决定研究从哪里开始,创新决定研究是否真正向前.没有问题的创新,是空洞的炫技;没有推进的问题,仍然停在原地.这里说的“创新为王”,不是把创新抬到问题之上,而是在真问题之后继续追问真推进.置于1945年《科学:无尽的前沿》到2026年《科学:新的黄金时代》的历史脉络中,本文把创新理解为真问题上的真实增量,并把这种增量压实为三个相互牵引的层面:多知道过去不知道的,是知识增量;多能做过去做不到的,是能力增量;使原本不可观测、不可计算、不可设计、不可验证的问题进入新的可达域,是可达边界增量.从0到1和从1到N,是创新向前走的两种方式:前者打开入口,后者把入口做深、做稳、做成可使用、可继承的知识和能力.伪创新不是与二者并列的第三种推进,而是只有新外观而没有真增量的失真状态.创新可以落在问题、方法、机制、系统和范式等不同形态上,它们的作用范围不同,却不是一部机械的高低阶梯.真问题既可来自国家任务、工程现场和临床需求,也可来自暂时看不到用途、但确实触及未知世界的基本问题.真正的创新主张,要说清它锚定了什么真问题,相对什么基线增加了什么,证据能支持到哪里,结论又在什么边界内成立.人工智能不仅降低了“看上去像创新”的门槛,也开始进入假设生成、模型发现、实验设计和结果验证,扩大科研的可达域.越是如此,作者、教师、审稿人、编辑和学术共同体越要守住问题、增量、证据和边界.
Abstract:The fifth editorial, After Tools, Problems Remain, argued that human judgment must not be surrendered to powerful tools. The sixth, Problem as Foundation, brought research back to real objects, contradictions, and boundaries. This editorial takes the next step: once a real problem has been established, what does it mean for research to genuinely move forward? A problem governs the starting point; innovation governs the advance. No problem means empty novelty; no advance means that the problem remains where it began.Placed in the historical arc from Science: the endless frontier (1945) to science: a new golden age (2026), this editorial defines innovation as a substantive increment on a real problem. Such an increment may enlarge knowledge, capability, or the accessible boundary of inquiry: we may know what was previously unknown, do what was previously impossible, or bring a problem previously beyond observation, computation, design, or verification into reach. Zero-to-one opens an entry point, whereas one-to-N develops that entry point into reliable, usable, and transferable knowledge or capability. Pseudo-innovation is not a third mode of advance, but an appearance of novelty without a substantive increment.Innovation may occur in problem formulation, method, mechanism, system capability, or paradigm. Real problems may arise from national missions, engineering practice, and clinical needs, but also from fundamental questions whose use cannot yet be foreseen. Artificial intelligence is expanding the accessible domain of research by entering hypothesis generation, model discovery, experimental design, and validation; at the same time, it lowers the threshold for work to look innovative. A defensible claim must therefore identify the real problem, state the baseline and increment, present evidence commensurate with the claim, and define its boundary. For Applied Mathematics and Mechanics, the final question remains whether a study has produced a real advance on a real problem.
-
Key words:
- innovation /
- substantive increment /
- real problem /
- accessible boundary /
- zero-to-one /
- one-to-N /
- artificial intelligence /
- community judgment
-
Bush V. Science, the endless frontier[R]. Washington, D.C.: United States Government Printing Office, 1945. [2]Kratsios M. Science: a new golden age[R]. Washington, D.C.: White House Office of Science and Technology Policy, 2026. [3]卢天健. 工具之后, 问题仍在——从有限元软件的冲击到人工智能时代人的成长[J]. 应用数学和力学, 2026,47(6): 687-698.(Lu Tianjian. After tools, problems remain: from the impact of finite element software to human growth in the age of artificial intelligence[J].Applied Mathematics and Mechanics,2026,47(6): 687-698. (in Chinese)) [4]卢天健. 问题为本——真实问题、伪问题与虚构性问题设置的学术边界[J]. 应用数学和力学, 2026,47(8): 959-977.(Lu Tianjian. Questions as the foundation: academic boundaries among genuine questions, pseudo-questions, and fabricated problem settings[J].Applied Mathematics and Mechanics,2026,47(8): 959-977. (in Chinese)) [5]卢天健. 桥仍在,河向前[J]. 应用数学和力学, 2026,47(1): ⅰ-ⅳ. (Lu Tianjian. The current runs while the bridge holds [J].Applied Mathematics and Mechanics,2026,47(1): ⅰ-ⅳ. (in Chinese)) [6]卢天健. 河流的新航道——应用数学与力学的学科再定向[J]. 应用数学和力学, 2026,47(5): 529-540.(Lu Tianjian. The river’s new channels: reorienting applied mathematics and mechanics[J].Applied Mathematics and Mechanics,2026,47(5): 529-540. (in Chinese)) [7]卢天健. 为什么科学研究必须坚持“四性”——关于重要性、必要性、创新性与可行性的几点思考[J]. 应用数学和力学, 2026,47(4): 391-403.(Lu Tianjian. Why scientific research must uphold the four essential criteria: reflections on significance, necessity, originality, and feasibility[J].Applied Mathematics and Mechanics,2026,47(4): 391-403. (in Chinese)) [8]Chen X, Ti F, Li M X, et al. Theory of fluid saturated porous media with surface effects[J].Journal of the Mechanics and Physics of Solids,2021,151: 104392. [9]孙学超, 刘少宝, 林敏, 等. 生物热-力-电生理耦合学[J]. 应用数学和力学, 2024,45(6): 651-669.(Sun Xuechao, Liu Shaobao, Lin Min, et al. The bio-thermo-mechano-electrophysiology[J].Applied Mathematics and Mechanics,2024,45(6): 651-669. (in Chinese)) [10]Wang Y J, Zou G J, Gao H J. Mechano-X:a paradigm for mechanics-based interdisciplinary innovation[J].MechanoEngineering,2026,1(1): 010801. [11]卢天健, 孟晗, 姜永烽. AI赋能结构设计[J]. 应用数学和力学, 2026,47(3): 257-262.(Lu Tianjian, Meng Han, Jiang Yongfeng. AI enables structural design[J].Applied Mathematics and Mechanics,2026,47(3): 257-262. (in Chinese)) [12]Herrmann L, Kollmannsberger S. Deep learning in computational mechanics: a review[J].Computational Mechanics,2024,74: 281-331. [13]康瑞, 李雪, 孟晗, 等. 轻巧-承力-功能一体化超结构: 概念、设计及应用[J]. 应用数学和力学, 2024,45(8): 949-973.(Kang Rui, Li Xue, Meng Han, et al. Ultralight, compact, and load-bearing multifunctional metastructures: concept, design and applications[J].Applied Mathematics and Mechanics,2024,45(8): 949-973. (in Chinese)) [14]胡海岩, 乔栋, 李翔宇, 等. 力学工程问题[M]. 北京: 科学出版社, 2024.(Hu Haiyan, Qiao Dong, Li Xiangyu,et al.Engineering Issues in Mechanics[M]. Beijing: Science Press, 2024. (in Chinese)) [15]杨卫. 力学基本问题[M]. 北京: 科学出版社, 2024.(Yang Wei.Basic Issues in Mechanics[M]. Beijing: Science Press, 2024. (in Chinese)) [16]Lu T J. What is MechanoEngineering?[J].MechanoEngineering,2026,1(1): 010401. [17]Zhang C, Zhu H, Ren X, et al. Mechanics-driven nuclear localization of YAP can be reversed by N-cadherin ligation in mesenchymal stem cells[J].Nature Communications,2021,12: 6229. [18]ClinicalTrials.gov. NCT06896747. Evaluating mechanically engineered stem cell exosomes for treating endometrial injury: a clinical study[EB/OL]. [2026-08-13]. https://clinicaltrials.gov/study/NCT06896747. -
计量
- 文章访问数: 151
- HTML全文浏览量: 26
- PDF下载量: 19
- 被引次数: 0
下载:
渝公网安备50010802005915号